Showing posts with label Concepts. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Concepts. Show all posts

Wednesday, 17 February 2016

Audio Conjuring don't come easy! - A Case Study: the Kii Audio Three

This audio replay component is an interesting example of the dilemma the industry is in at the moment. It's an active speaker system, which includes the capability of digital input - meaning, that all is needed for reproduction to occur is to feed the right input with material from any capable source, a very cheap storage device that can output digital audio would be sufficient; it has been designed and developed by a highly capable audio circuitry design engineer, Bruno Putzeys, he has an excellent reputation for conceiving and bringing into existence fresh approaches to elements of the audio reproduction chain, high levels of praise have been bestowed upon products originating from him, both people coming from a technical viewpoint and those only interested in "what it sounds like" are impressed by his efforts ... but, this new product, under the banner Kii, has been getting very mixed reports - everything from "dreadful to listen to", to "can't imagine it being better!!"... so, what's going on ??

Particular of note is that very negative reports have been garnered from its presence at major audio shows in the USA, the two most recent being RMAF and CES. People who are familiar with decent audio sound are completely unimpressed, indeed found its sound quite offputting - at CES 2016 nearly every well known reviewer completely ignored it in their summaries. Why??

Luckily, a means of hearing what it sounded like at CES 2016, at least at one point of time, is available: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XZt6DokXi1s, a video report by AVshowreports on YouTube. This includes a long segment at the end of the clip of the speakers in operation - and, it is relatively easy, even on a YouTube video(!), to hear that the sound is deficient - it has a "shouty", uncomfortable quality to it, which seems to get worse as the clip progresses ... what is happening?

And ... just read a post on What's Best Forum: http://www.whatsbestforum.com/showthread.php?18437-Kii-Three-speaker-review-english-version&p=379168&viewfull=1#post379168. These are the impressions by a buyer of the units, who will use them to analyse recording mixes ... and his comments are extremely familiar: the quality is close, very, oh so very close to being "there" - yet, there is something not quite right ...

To me, these are the classic symptoms of digitally based replay which has the potential of producing superb sound ... when it is in the "zone" the result is music which is immensely satisfying to experience, but, the slightest weakness in the integrity of the complete chain can easily cause a quality which is very unpleasant to listen to, a complete contrast to the previous situation - Jekyll and Hyde, if you will ... hopefully, the degradation is not too great; but if it is not resolved then the playback will never totally satisfy ... which it is always capable of achieving, if the right efforts are made.

The big question is, will anyone go to this effort? If it doesn't happen then it's likely this product will also join the long, long list of also-rans, it will slowly fade as a prime target for enthusiasm by searching music lovers ...

Friday, 25 December 2015

"The essential characteristic of the original signal" ... ?

Referring to a recording, of course. I just saw this phrase commented upon in a thread on an audio forum, its significance or meaning pooh-poohed ...

However, a competent playback system does allow this to emerge, in usually glorious ways! For someone who has never experienced this occurring it might seem almost magical, and in many ways it is remarkable, because it demonstrates the ability of the combination of ear and brain to decipher, unravel a consistent picture of a sound event in a fashion which minimises disturbing or unwanted aural artifacts not relevant to the musical performance. Especially on very poor, ancient recordings, full of detritus - on a typical, ambitious hifi system these will sound absolutely appalling, completely unlistenable to; every defect in the sound will be highly magnified, and will overwhelmingly dominate the listening experience - subjectively !!

Are we listening to the "essential characteristic of the original signal" in that situation? Of course not, our hearing is so distracted by the "noise" and "distortion" that accompanies the "signal", the musical event, that there is almost no chance of relating in an enjoyable way to the latter. So, what to do about that? Some of the options are: never listen to that recording; or, filter out by brute force frequency response manipulation, in the replay chain, what seems to be the worst unpleasantness; or ... raise the standard of the replay mechanism to the point that the human hearing mechanism is fed enough relatively clean information, allowing the ear/brain to do vital, internal, in the brain, filtering, without conscious effort. Even though the last choice may seem fanciful to many, it in fact is done all the time in the "real world" - a good example is listening to a musician busker on a busy street, performing with no sound reinforcing gear, having huge amounts of unrelated racket 'interfering' with the musical sound. The "essential characteristic of the original signal" is very obvious here; some passing by may completely ignore the performance, be oblivious to it, but others will have no trouble "tuning in" to what's important to them at that moment, and enjoy the efforts of the musician.

This should be the aim of quality audio reproduction, and is always achievable. The integrity of the production of the "art" of the music is retained in recordings, and it is only a matter of raising the standard of the replay chain to the point where one's hearing is able to distinguish the "essential characteristics" without conscious effort - this is the essence of the Art of Audio Conjuring!

Wednesday, 23 December 2015

The only real problem to solve in Audio, is Attitude

Problem, what problem? Some people might claim that everything is known to made reproduction of recordings as good as one could want - and in one sense they are right. But, if that's the case, why do so many systems, even those which are expensive and lavishly indulged in in terms of time and effort, sound very little like the "real thing", or just downright weird? Of course there are some extremely competent audio systems around, but they're thin on the ground, they stand out as being 'special' when one comes across them!

So, the "problem" is that one can't assemble an audio system from standard, off the shelf components and have it "sound good" - every time. To counter that, my experience over many decades, is that just about every assembly of sound gear, no matter how inexpensive, can be made to come up to, tweaked to an acceptable standard, and with extra effort be evolved into a mechanism that produces highly satisfying audio, and, yes, even conjures ...

What is clear, something recently even more strongly confirmed, is that there is very little desire to think beyond the standard cliches of audiophile think: "it's all about the frequency response"; "loudspeakers are what cripples the sound no matter what"; "huge effort must be put into creating a perfect acoustic environment for the audio equipment"; etc ... but a little thought puts these ideas into better perspective: an actual musical instrument or voice of a person in the room or any natural, non-reinforced sound doesn't require any of these sort of shenanigans, it will still have the impact of the "real thing", every time, irrespective of how casually the sound is produced, and how non attentively one listens to it. And the latter is my experience of competent playback: when it works well there is the same impact as hearing 'natural' sounds, no, absolutely zero, excuses or allowances have to be made for the fact that it is "only a recording" ...

It's easy to see that the attitude of the majority in audio land doesn't echo this thinking at all; firstly by reading what they have to say about things, and secondly by listening to what the vast majority of systems produce, the acoustic end result. Sometimes spectacular in a circus-like manner, often disappointing, irritating, fatiguing, uninteresting to listen to - nearly always sounding like a "hifi system", very rarely they are convincing.

But there is a solution ... just get a few people thinking that there may be a smarter way, which in essence is to view the business of reproducing sound from a recording as a process which has to have minimal flaws in every aspect, every area, to get a worthwhile result. Yes, people worry now about "flaws", but they're usually the 'wrong' flaws - they are of low importance, they matter little in the quest to produce an illusion that the ear/brain combination can believe in ... it's only a shift in attitude that's actually required, to focus on the key flaws that make the crucial difference in the quality of the sound that's heard.

Monday, 14 December 2015

Yes, Virginia, it is like cleaning a window ...

It has become a cliche that improving playback sound is like having a clearer 'window' onto the recording, but, that remains a very apt analogy - sorry!! Achieving convincing, realistic recreation of a recorded musical event requires that the listener focuses only on the scene beyond the window - the latter representing the mechanism of the playback system, and the former being the actual 'data' encoded on the recording. A window that is dirty to some degree, or that distorts the image of what is on the other side can be largely ignored depending upon one's mood, and especially if the landscape beyond is already well known ... but removing the glass from that window, suddenly, will be quite noticeable, or dramatic, or even an epiphany ...

If an individual is content to always observe the world through that lesser window, oblivious to its effect, then that's fine - but if one were to be exposed to the "reality" beyond the imperfect glass barricade, then a burning desire to never be aware of that window lessening the impact of what one is seeing will form in many people. That it is impossible to actually eliminate the window may be part of the deal - you always require a playback system to experience recorded music - but your awareness of any filtering effect should be as close to zero as possible.

Thus, the exercise is to make the window as "perfect" as possible. And there are many ads of window cleaners where the punchline is that a person walks into the glass, not picking there is an "illusion" of nothing being in his way ... this is what one is after in audio - and, fortunately, it's very achievable  ...

A large part of the "battle" in getting the glass 'transparent' enough is not understanding what audible artifacts are due to the glass, not realising that supposedly bad recordings, say, come across that way because the mind is struggling to make sense of the fine detail beyond the imperfect pane - many times it's easier to give up, mentally, and simply decide that the music is so flawed in the recording that nothing can be done about it ... but, nothing could be further from the truth ...

And so a key first step is learning to recognise what the imperfect window is doing to what you're perceiving: luckily, in the visual area everyone can easily adjust the focus of their eyes so that they "look" at the dirt on the window, the scene beyond is blurred out. People can use various ways, intuitive most of the time, to register what's wrong with the glass, being able to completely ignore what is actually seen through the pane - and then clean up and correct the window. Unfortunately, in the aural area, most people are not so well attuned to what's going on, and haven't learnt to switch, shift their focus on the sounds in what they hear.

One needs to be able to "see" the dirt in the playback, and know it's not part of the recording, the scene beyond, itself. This can be learnt, and once acquired, like riding a bike, never goes away. Then, you will motivated to fix the problem, and ,be far better equipped to make the right moves in sorting things out ...

Friday, 20 November 2015

Why does conventionally set up audio normally fail to 'conjure'?

There are many factors at work, but the fundamental reason is that insufficient experimenting and research has gone into understanding how people can pick up on subtle clues in what they're hearing, usually unconscious, which allows them to easily separate 'real' sounds from an attempted mimicking of such via a high fidelity system. Most playback manifests clearly audible "flaws", which then makes it trivially easy for the mind to "spot the fake", and once this happens the mind will automatically keep referencing these "defects", reinforcing one's awareness that the illusion has failed. An analogy would be watching a stage magician after being made aware somehow of how he does it - the tricks will be quite obvious, and part of one will be somewhat surprised that others in the audience don't also see how the manipulation occurs - your attention has been drawn, irreversibly, to the "chinks in the armour" of the stage act, and while you may be impressed by the magician's skill you no longer marvel at the "trick" itself.

It is unfortunate that during the history of audio reproduction that more in depth examination of the crucial factors didn't happen - many of the pioneers had an intuitive understanding of what was necessary, but this didn't evolve into an industry wide set of highly effective standards and rules which everyone could usefully reference; Paul Klipsch is a good example of such a person.

So, the illusion usually fails ... again, why? The answer, because the distortion, meaning elements of the audible sound which don't match the recording content, is too obvious, and intrusive. Most of the industry with a technical focus has become infatuated with easily obtainable raw numbers on behaviours of the individual components of a system: the source mechanism, the amplifier, the speakers exist in completely different spaces, are seen as separate units on a test bench; the overall performance of a complete system in its final environment is seen as something that is too hard to measure - that aspect which is in fact the most important of all is never sensibly dealt with. Unfortunately, the types of distortion which will always cause the illusion to collapse or fail to manifest easily arise in an end system, many times as a result of interaction between the components and the environment in which it finds itself. The fact that the "measurers" are remarkably blind to this is a bind that the audio industry is currently trapped in, and there are no signs as yet of any meaningful progress ...

But fortunately this does not stop the individual being able to bypass these limitation of thinking, and now and again one can read how this has been done by someone who has chanced upon a lucky combination of factors that reduce the key distortion sufficiently.

Friday, 16 October 2015

What do I mean, Audio Conjuring ??

Simply put, the intention is to create an illusion that one is hearing the "real thing" when listening to replay of musical recordings - which then brings in one's interpretation of the word "real", in this context. Most would have an intuitive understanding of what I'm getting at, a simple example is a CD recording of some classical, solo piano music: if this is always able to "fool" you and anyone else into thinking that there is a real grand piano, and real, highly competent pianist in your home, say, both on a casual coming across the sound of it happening, and also when closely, carefully listening to the quality of the tone and other elements of how the sound comes across.

This just then naturally extends to any and all recordings being played on the audio system: they never draw attention to the fact that they are a 'fake', they are convincing in their presentation. One should never be aware that you are listening to an electronic, mechanical contrivance doing the work of generating the sound in the space - if this happens, then the conjuring "trick" has failed.

It's as simple as that ...